Is aluminum roofing better than shingles?

Firstly, there are different types of both aluminum roofing and shingles.

Aluminum shingles – some people like the look, many don’t. They are fairly fragile to impact but otherwise can last 10–15 years. Inexpensive. Aluminum requires precautions when touching other metals.

Aluminum sheet or standing seam roofing – very distinctive look. Considered one of the best sloped roof types for longevity. Expensive.

Wood shingles – Inexpensive and durable. It is combustible which has restricted its use in many areas.

Asphaltic or composition shingles – Inexpensive and very durable. Generally considered to be one of the best roofs, but is also considered to be less attractive than other options.